I left my cufflinks in France.
They are sitting in a lacquered orange jewelry box on my bedside table on Mont Boron, three thousand miles and one ocean east of the wrist that needs them, because I packed the way a man packs for a wedding he is not at all nervous about, which is to say I packed the tuxedo and the shirt and the shoes and the whole considered surface of myself, in the rehearsed way I have been dressing for red carpets and black tie my whole career, and on this occasion I forgot the two small silver mementos shaped like my deeply missed English bulldogs, Ladybug and Dozer, one for each wrist. Joe bought them from Paul Smith, no relation, years ago before they were both in my life, ahead of the times spent together. Sterling bits that hold the whole construction together at the wrist and, it turns out, across several chapters of my life.
Ladybug, the little one, came first. She arrived in my apartment in West Hollywood after the Greek Goddess and I had been working together at the studio for a secure amount of time, one of the most talented and caring women I have ever known, a friend to all animals, who kept a beloved pack of poodles in the kind of house celebrity money affords in the hills, white columns and a circular drive ringed with ivy and topiary. Ladybug came with the house, an agreement the goddess made with the owner that the clearly neglected animal would stay with the property and find a good home, and Goddess knew my love of bulldogs and knew at once we would be right together. Dozer came a less glamorous but no less fortuitous way, another co-worker’s dog, delightfully grumpy and lumpy and picked on by the other animals in his household, so I benefited from the mismatch and, after Ladybug passed, was happy to fill the apartment again with another snorty, lovely mess. Dozer did not make the move to France. He was another loss of that very tough year of 2020. Twelve years of borrowed time between the two of them, each one marking a chapter the way only our animals can.
Unlike an international move, you cannot fasten a French cuff with hope and moxie. It needs the hardware. And the hardware was in the orange box, in the velvet slot, in the recess, in the protected place I had flown away from.
So El Jefe went to his drawer.
NickDear’s father opened a drawer in Maryland and took out a spare pair of his own, and put them in a bag, and got on a plane, and carried them across the country so that I would be properly dressed to stand up at the family wedding. This is the whole story, and I could almost stop here, because everything I have been trying to say all summer is contained in that one small errand, but I want to walk you through the city first, because the city spent two days handing me the same lesson and I did not understand it was one lesson until the cufflinks were already in the air.
To mobilize the links, there was a phone call from the hotel, made on NickDear’s phone, so of course El Jefe thought he had Nick on the line, and he was giving him the business, the rough affectionate hard time a father gives a son, the earned roughness of blood that has been proven so many times it no longer needs to be gentle. Then, somewhere in the speakerphone request, he realized it was me. And his voice changed, instantly, to the sweetest human, careful and warm, the tone you use for something you are still tender with because it is newer and you think you have not yet earned the sandpaper. Two registers of love in one call, and I heard both, and the gentle one was for the son-in-law and I have thought about that gentleness for two days. Two bulldogs and one bichon ago the sentence I am about to write was unthinkable, and this weekend it is an ordinary courteous errand: the husband’s father is flying cufflinks across a seaboard so his son’s husband can stand up at a wedding. No speech was made. The whole arc of acceptance, compressed into a man going to a drawer.
Let me tell you about the city those cufflinks were arriving to, a city I had not walked in nearly two decades. There is a particular arrogance to moving through Boston on a hazy memory of the eighteenth century, and I am embarrassed by how much of the American Revolution I had quietly filed into the back corners of my middle-aged mind, as if those high school lessons were background noise meant for someone else. Much to NickDear’s annoyance, I am a man who likes to read a plaque so, standing on cobblestones that saw the first real spilling of blood for an idea, I felt a sharp, sudden debt, the cost of having brushed aside the foundational stories of my own country because they were inconvenient to remember before boarding a flight. Part of it is the easy privilege of West Coast geography, where history is measured in decades and the dirt feels young, where you are raised looking toward the ocean and the future, detached from the cramped, bloody cradle where the whole enterprise was dragged into being. The morning after we landed, missing the strength of the Italian coffee at home, I decided some American history was in order, and left the hotel, itself built on the site of a buried elevated highway, one of the most expensive public works ever undertaken to rescue a city from its own bad planning, and walked the old town from the harbor up.
Boston is a city built on made land, and once you know that, you cannot stop seeing it. I stood on State Street, which once ran dead straight from the seat of power to the sea, the water lapping almost at the door of the Old State House, and everything between where I stood and the current waterline is fill, dredged and dumped and built upon, the harbor pushed back to make more city. The most solid-looking ground in America is simply something they poured. I was standing on the seam, the exact hinge where the original shoreline ends and the made land begins, and nobody around me was thinking about it because the seam does not show anymore. Here was the whole Venetian trick again, the beautiful surface that hides the labor and the water underneath, except Boston does not even have Venice’s excuse of marble. It just fills the harbor, paves it over, forgets, and gets right back to work.
On the roof of that old Provincial State House stood the lion and the unicorn, the crown’s arms, England’s lion and Scotland’s chained unicorn, marking the king’s authority over Massachusetts. In July of 1776 they read the Declaration to the city from that balcony and the crowd tore the lion and the unicorn down and burned them in the street. The ones up there now are replacements, re-hung in the last century, the city carefully re-installing the symbol of the power it overthrew, because the story does not stay legible without the thing that was torn down. You put the crown back up so people can see that you took it apart.
The chained unicorn on the Boston roof was not the first one I stood under this year. Back in the spring, in a square in Montpellier, the Place de la Canourgue, there is a fountain called the Fontaine des Licornes, inaugurated in 1776, the same year the crowd in Boston was pulling the chained one down and burning it in the street. The same year, the same beast, one in flames on a roof in Massachusetts and one rising in gold over a gleaming fountain in the south of France. The Montpellier one is not in chains, it stands there with its horn catching the afternoon light, entirely unbothered by the date or its meaning, and I stood in front of it on a golden summer day and felt, without being able to explain why, familiar. It is the unicorn the Boston one becomes when the collar finally burns off. The wild thing they said was theirs, standing free in the sun, and it is so pretty, and that is also true, and it does not need to be more than that.
I have spent a season writing about the reset move, the new thing built around the old while the old keeps working, San Giorgio’s facade raised from a dead man’s model, the tarnished angel reglued, and here it was in American brass, the overthrown crown rehung to keep the overthrow readable.
Out front, at ankle height, a ring of cobblestones on a traffic island marks where five men were shot in 1770, the first blood of the Revolution, the first of them Crispus Attucks, which is one of the better names in history. People walk over it all day without looking down, this founding wound set into the pavement at the exact height easily overlooked, and yet placed so you cannot quite miss it. We would have welcome drinks later at the Samuel Adams brewery a few blocks off. Adams was the one who called the events of that day a massacre, while to this day the British refer to it, politely, as the Incident on King Street. Welcome indeed.
We walked on, NickDear ducking into an American pharmacy, the kind where the razors sit behind lexan and the deodorant is locked out of reach and must be asked for, and I stood outside the Old South Meeting House, reading. The plain Puritan hall with no altar and no grandeur, built for worship and for argument in equal measure, where thousands packed in on a December night in 1773 waiting for the answer about the tea, and when the answer was no, they poured out to the wharf and threw it in the harbor. Griffin’s Wharf, where the most famous act of American defiance happened, is now dry land. They filled that cove in the eighteen hundreds and the defiance is buried inland now, under the made city, on ground that is no longer even near the water. And the meeting house carries its wound the way the good ones do: during the siege the British gutted it, tore out the pews, laid down tanbark, and used the room where independence was argued as a riding school for their cavalry. Horses in the sanctuary. It survived that, and survived near-demolition a century later, and refused both times to be plastered over.
One of the gifts the move has given me is another perspective on time, so of course I kept asking, the whole walk, what France was up to at each of these moments, because France is always in the room, and on this trip especially she cannot help herself. The night of the Tea Party, Louis XV was in the last year of his life at Versailles, his court watching the friction between Britain and her colonies with the keen interest of a nation that had just lost a war to Britain and wanted her humbled. Within three years France was secretly shipping the colonists arms and powder. Within five she openly joined the war, and that is the reason America won.
The history lessons started to come back, cobwebs getting dusted away in the harbor breeze. The country I flew home from was the silent partner of the country I flew home to, from the very start. And the place I actually live, Nice, La Turbie, was not even France yet in 1773. It belonged to the Kingdom of Sardinia, ruled from Turin, and did not become French until 1860. I live in a place that was still becoming France while America was still becoming America. Two unfinished countries, ninety years apart, and now I have a foot in each.
Just outside the meeting house is a memorial with another plaque. The Irish Famine Memorial where two streets cross, two bronze family groups, one starving on the Irish shore and one arriving nourished in Boston, the same body twice with the whole Atlantic in the gap between them. The plaque says thirty-seven thousand Irish refugees landed here in a single year, 1847, fleeing a hunger that killed a million and drove out a million more, and they came to a city that did not want them, No Irish Need Apply, and took it over anyway, ran its government within two generations. The memorial is, apparently, one of the most mocked sculptures in the city, and I understand why, because the before-and-after is arranged a little too neatly, and too graphically, the arrival redeeming the famine too cleanly, the migliorato problem in a monument, the loss made too legible, too reassuring. I felt the flinch and the power at the same time and did not resolve it. But the thing under it is true and not too neat at all: America is built on the drowned and the fled, the people the old world exported when it could not feed them, and I had flown across that same ocean, in the opposite direction, for the most ordinary and hopeful reason a body ever crosses water, which is a wedding. Just as I was starting to get either a little maudlin or frightened by two gentlemen who were either unhoused or tied way more into the fashion sense of those younger than I am, NickDear came out, razor blades purchased, and we kept on.
Franklin stands in a courtyard by the old city hall, and I could not walk past him. Boston made him, raised him, and Boston could not hold him. Apprenticed to a brother who beat him, he broke the apprenticeship illegally and fled at seventeen, a fugitive, and never really came home. The city distrusted his ease and his wit and his irreligion. He became the most beloved American in the world everywhere but here, respected in Philadelphia and then adored, most of all, in France, where he put on a plain brown coat and a fur cap as a costume for exactly what Paris wanted to see, and flirted in the salons and ran his press and played his chess and drank well and closed the alliance that won the war.
He wept when he had to leave France and France mourned his leaving harder than his own country did. He had to leave the place that made him in order to become himself, and the statue in Boston is the city’s late and quiet apology. I stood in front of the most famous dropout in American history, a man who found himself only by crossing an ocean, and I did not have to explain to myself why I was moved.
And then, after lunch and across the water, on the far side of the harbor, the obelisk.
I craned my neck at the Bunker Hill Monument, two hundred and twenty-one feet of Quincy granite, one of the grandest war memorials in the country, and it commemorates a defeat. For those of us who let our history lessons lapse: the Americans lost that battle. The British took the hill. What makes it worth two hundred feet of granite is that the amateurs dug into that slope made the finest army in the world pay so catastrophically to take it, over a thousand British casualties, a staggering toll of officers dead, that everyone on both sides understood the rabble could stand against an empire and bleed it white. It was the loss that proved they could win. The tower is not celebrating a victory. It is celebrating the cost. It is a monument to how much it hurt the other side to beat you.
I have spent this whole trip, this whole season, saying that something has to stay broken for the thing to mean anything, and here a nation built two hundred and twenty-one feet of granite to say the same thing, on purpose, at height. This is the exact mirror of where I dropped the dogs the day we left. La Turbie, above and to the east of my own house, is a victor’s trophy, the Tower of Augustus, Rome’s tower on the mountain announcing who conquered whom, the winner’s monument. In its day, the cylindrical style would have rhymed with the circular colonnade of the Jefferson Memorial. Bunker Hill is the loser’s obelisk, built by the side that got pushed off the hill, insisting the losing was the beginning. Two stone towers, two battles, one for the empire that won and one for the rabble that lost well, and I have stood under both inside of ten days.
We walked back down the other side through Charlestown, the masts of the USS Constitution showing over the clapboard and brick, where it was pointed out that the neighborhood’s gas lamps had once been marked for replacement as the city tried to modernize, and only local politics and sheer ineptitude derailed the trade of historic gas for efficient electric. Today the lamps are the prime selling point every agent features to earn a commission. The flaw the city failed to fix, turned to the thing that sells the house.
Up on Beacon Hill, around Louisburg Square, I walked past some of the most beautiful row houses in the city, ringing a private keyed park in the center, a very London arrangement in this new society across the Atlantic. On some of the windows a few of the panes are lavender. Glass shipped from Europe in the eighteen twenties with a trace of manganese in it that the sunlight, over decades, turned purple. It was a manufacturing flaw. And because you could not fake it, because it only came from being old and original and standing in the light for a hundred years, the flaw became the most coveted thing on the street, proof the glass was real. The imperfection became the mark of belonging. The thing they would once have called a defect, the light turned to treasure, and it cannot be bought or counterfeited, it only comes from having been made a certain way and having weathered a certain amount of sun.
I stood on that genteel brick sidewalk, a man who was turned away from a Venice pavilion ten days ago for his arrangement of living together, flown home through airports that clocked my arrival on video, here in this city for a wedding, and the street handed me a windowpane whose flaw is lavender and whose flaw is the whole point. Lavender, the color they used to pin on men like me as a warning. Taken, and worn on purpose, and set into the front of the finest houses on the hill, where the light comes through it every afternoon and makes it worth more than the clear glass beside it. I did not have to work to feel that one. It arrived whole.
So that is the city the cufflinks had crossed into. A place built on filled harbor and cut hills, that rehangs the crown it burned so the burning stays legible, that buries its defiance under made land and marks its founding wound at ankle height, that built its grandest tower to a defeat, that was made by the fled and the drowned who crossed an ocean for hope, that turns a flaw in the glass to the proof of belonging. Every stop the same lesson. The cost is the meaning. The thing they called broken is the treasure. You do not hide the seam. You point at it.
El Jefe waved off my thanks as he handed over the rescue links. The wave-off is its own kind of love, the errand made ordinary on purpose so nobody has to make a speech. They are old Indian Head pennies bound in silver bezels, worn to bronze, the feathered profile on one cuff and the oak wreath with its faded ONE CENT on the other. There is a quiet, perfect irony in stepping out to a black-tie affair held together by two nineteenth-century copper coins. Not the bulldogs. But a stroke of generous emergency grace.
And that is the whole chain of it, standing at the wrist. My own dogs, gone, waiting in the orange box on Mont Boron. Another man’s pennies, lent for a night, worn to bronze by a century of other hands. And someday these Paul Smith bulldogs of mine, once they have a few more wears and a good polish, sent on to my godson, Joe’s boy, who has lost bulldogs of his own, for the weddings and the carpets he will walk after his own graduation, where they will mean something different for him than they ever meant for me. Fastening passed down, borrowed, passed on. It holds the cuff for exactly as long as it needs to, which is the evening, which is the part that matters, which is the only part I flew across the ocean to be present for.
My own cufflinks are still in the box on Mont Boron. Word came that the canicule broke overnight, a torrential thunderstorm that will have terrified my sensitive truffle dog and the poodle both. The Mediterranean is pouring rain on the terrace right now, the drain by the stair backing up, the water finding the middle of the tiles, and I am not there. I am here, on made land, in a borrowed fastening, standing up for love in a country built by people who crossed the water for exactly that.